Hi guys, and another Everlane review for you today! When it comes to Everlane shoes, I pretty much try everything they come out with (except for their boots since I have my trusty 'ole black rag & bone pair). But I'm always down to try a good pair of kitten heels, so I couldn't wait to try Everlane's Editor Heel. I first saw them over at Mademoiselle, who featured them before their official release and they looked so good on her!
I ordered them in my usual Everlane size of 8 (I'm usually between a 7.5 and 8 but size up to 8 for Everlane because I find their shoes to be on the narrow side). And for once, the size 8 was too large. You can tell in the pictures below that I have quite a gap at the back between my heel and the shoe. Because of that I can't give an accurate description of how the shoes fit in general (like I'm not sure if I had gotten the right size whether or not the heel would pinch). Also the width felt generous, but again the shoe was too large. So I would say make sure you stick with your normal size on these shoes (or go down half a size from your usual Everlane size).
I did notice that the shoes are slightly lighter in color than in Everlane's pictures on the website. I prefer the lighter color since it makes it more of a nude on me. I also really liked the squarish toe box but pointy toe. Their shape is super flattering!
In the end, though, I returned these shoes and decided against ordering another pair in a smaller size. Since I already have a favorite pair of kitten heels (these Valentino rock studs) and a heel I would wear for more casual occasions (Everlane's Day Heels), I figured I didn't need another pair of heels.